top of page

How to Generate Wealth with the ‘Positivity Effect’ as We Gain Experience

Writer: Rattan Deep
Rattan Deep
1 hour ago
5 min read

Investors tend to become more conservative as they grow older. The enthusiasm to explore opportunities, experiment with investments and take calculated risks that we display in our twenties and thirties often gives way to a preference for stability and capital preservation as we move into our fifties and sixties.


There are understandable reasons for this shift. We have more to lose. Financial assets have accumulated, family responsibilities have increased, and lifestyle commitments have become more demanding. A financial setback that might have been manageable at 30 could have a much greater impact at 60. We also have fewer earning years ahead and less time to recover from a substantial loss.


But there is another, less obvious reason why our appetite for risk changes. We tend to remember our financial disappointments much more vividly than our successes.

Think about how we travel. Many of us remember the train or flight we missed. We remember the frantic rush to the airport, the money lost and the inconvenience caused. Some might even preserve the ticket as a reminder. But how many of us keep a record of all the trains and flights we successfully boarded? How often do we recall the hundreds of journeys that went exactly as planned?


We don’t. Successful journeys become ordinary memories. The missed ones remain with us.

Something similar happens with investments.


An investor might have made ten investments over five years, eight of which generated attractive returns while two resulted in substantial losses. Yet, when discussing his investment experience a few years later, he is likely to recall the two that went wrong. The stock that fell 40%, the business investment that failed or the property that remained unsold. The profitable investments gradually fade into the background. Over time, these memories begin to influence not just how we look at the past, but also what we expect from the future.


There are three behavioural tendencies that help explain this.


Negativity bias makes us pay greater attention to negative experiences than positive ones. From an evolutionary perspective, recognising threats was important for survival. Missing an opportunity was less dangerous than failing to recognise a threat. This instinct continues to influence our financial behaviour. The pain of losing ₹10 lakh often feels considerably greater than the satisfaction of making an equivalent gain.

The availability heuristic influences how we assess probabilities. We tend to believe that something is more likely to happen if examples readily come to mind. An investor who repeatedly recalls a market crash or a failed investment may begin to believe that another loss is just around the corner. What is most memorable starts appearing most probable.

Loss aversion makes us particularly sensitive to losses. The work of Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky on Prospect Theory established that the psychological discomfort of losing is generally greater than the pleasure of an equivalent gain. As wealth accumulates, protecting what we have built can become emotionally more important than pursuing further growth.

There is also a connection between emotional experiences and memory formation. The brain’s memory systems interact with regions involved in processing emotional significance.

A substantial financial loss can trigger a stress response, making the circumstances surrounding it particularly memorable. This helps explain why the details of a painful investment experience can remain with us long after several successful investments have been forgotten. The problem is that our memories are not always a fair representation of our investment journey. And when we allow them to shape our expectations, we can become excessively cautious, sometimes without realising it.

Interestingly, psychology offers us another way of looking at ageing through a phenomenon known as the positivity effect.

Research by psychologist Laura Carstensen and others suggests that as people grow older, they often become more inclined to focus on and remember positive information. Their priorities gradually shift towards emotional well-being and meaningful experiences.

What if we consciously brought this perspective into our investment behaviour?

What if, instead of allowing two unsuccessful investments to define our investment journey, we gave equal importance to the eight that succeeded? This is not about ignoring losses, becoming blindly optimistic or taking risks without adequate assessment. It is about learning from setbacks without allowing them to dominate our perception of the future.

Experience should ideally make us better investors. We should become better at recognising opportunities, understanding market cycles, assessing businesses and distinguishing between temporary uncertainty and permanent impairment of capital.

We should also become more comfortable with the fact that not every investment will work out as expected. Even good decisions can produce unfavourable outcomes, and not every successful outcome is necessarily the result of a good decision.

The objective is to ensure that experience produces wisdom, not just caution.

A simple intervention: Maintain an investment decision journal

One way to achieve this is to maintain an investment decision journal.

The idea is not to create another record of portfolio performance or repeatedly revisit painful investment experiences. It is to capture the thinking behind our decisions and understand what those decisions teach us.

For every significant investment, record the rationale, the assumptions behind the decision, the risks identified, the expected downside and, eventually, the outcome.

More importantly, record what went right and what went wrong. If an investment loses 20%, was it because of inadequate research, overconfidence, herd mentality or an unrealistic assessment of the business? Or did the underlying assumptions remain valid, but an unforeseen event temporarily affected the outcome?

Equally, when an investment succeeds, understand why. Was it the quality of the underlying business, the valuation at which we invested, the patience to stay invested, an appropriate asset allocation or simply favourable market conditions?

A profitable outcome does not automatically validate a good decision, just as an investment loss does not necessarily indicate a bad one. What matters is the quality of the decision-making process. Periodically revisiting this journal helps us recognise recurring patterns, identify biases and, importantly, give our successful investment experiences their rightful place in our memory. It also helps us separate what we have learnt from what we have merely experienced. There is a difference.

As we grow older, the objective should not be to eliminate risk. It should be to become more discerning about the risks worth taking. Our accumulated experience is a valuable asset. It should help us avoid repeating mistakes, but it should not prevent us from recognising opportunities. If we allow a handful of painful experiences to overshadow years of successful decisions, we risk becoming prisoners of our own memories.

Perhaps the real advantage of growing older is not simply the wealth we accumulate, but the wisdom we develop in managing it.

At KompassIQ, we believe that good financial decisions are not just about knowing what can go wrong. They are also about recognising what has gone right, understanding why it happened and having the confidence to apply those lessons again.

Don’t just keep the tickets of missed trains and flights. Remember all the journeys you successfully completed. The same principle applies to investing. Let your experience make you a better investor, not a more fearful one.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Subscribe to our newsletter

bottom of page