top of page

How Your Upbringing Shapes Your Financial Decisions: Exploring Money Narratives

Jun 19

5 min read

0

0

Let’s face it—money isn’t just about numbers. It’s deeply personal, shaped by the stories we tell ourselves and the lessons we absorb growing up. Whether you’re a saver, a spender, or somewhere in between, your financial habits and decisions are often rooted in experiences from your childhood.

In The Psychology of Money, Morgan Housel dives deep into how our upbringing influences our relationship with money. Through real-life anecdotes and sharp insights, he shows us that understanding these “money narratives” is key to making smarter, more intentional financial choices. Let’s unpack this idea with stories from the book and explore how your past shapes your present—and what you can do about it.


What Are Money Narratives?

Money narratives are the subconscious beliefs and attitudes we develop about money based on our upbringing. These narratives shape everything from how we save and spend to how we think about risk, wealth, and security. For example, someone who grew up in a household where money was scarce might develop a scarcity mindset, hoarding cash out of fear of running out. On the flip side, someone raised in a family that valued spending freely might struggle with saving or delaying gratification.

Housel explains that these narratives aren’t inherently good or bad—they’re just lenses through which we view the world. But if left unexamined, they can lead to behaviors that don’t align with our goals or values. The first step to improving your financial life is recognizing the stories you’ve internalized and deciding whether they still serve you.


The Story of Two Investors: Fear vs. Opportunity

One of the most compelling examples in The Psychology of Money involves two investors with vastly different approaches to risk. One grew up during the Great Depression and saw firsthand how quickly fortunes could vanish. As an adult, he avoided stocks entirely, keeping his money in cash and bonds despite their lower returns. His fear of losing everything kept him financially secure but limited his wealth-building potential.

The other investor grew up in a household that embraced risk and entrepreneurship. He viewed market downturns not as threats but as opportunities to buy undervalued assets. While his approach came with volatility, it ultimately led to significant long-term gains.

This contrast highlights how upbringing shapes financial behavior. Neither investor was “right” or “wrong”—their decisions were simply reflections of the money narratives they inherited. The key takeaway? Understanding your own narrative can help you identify blind spots and make more balanced decisions.


The Tale of Ronald Read: Humility and Discipline

Another inspiring story from Housel’s book is that of Ronald Read, a janitor who quietly amassed an $8 million fortune through frugal living and disciplined investing. Raised in a modest household, Read learned early on the value of hard work and saving. His upbringing instilled a sense of humility and patience, which guided his financial decisions throughout his life.

Read didn’t chase trends or try to time the market. Instead, he stuck to a simple strategy of buying quality companies and holding them for decades. His success wasn’t due to luck or genius—it was the result of a money narrative that prioritized consistency over flashiness.

This story reminds us that your upbringing doesn’t have to limit you; it can also empower you. By reflecting on the lessons you’ve learned, you can build on the strengths of your narrative while addressing its weaknesses.


The Impact of Scarcity vs. Abundance Mindsets

Housel explores how growing up in environments of scarcity versus abundance shapes our financial behavior. For instance, someone who experienced financial hardship as a child might become hyper-focused on saving, even at the expense of enjoying life. While this mindset can foster discipline, it can also lead to missed opportunities or unnecessary deprivation.

On the other hand, someone raised in an environment of abundance might feel entitled to a certain lifestyle, leading to overspending or under-saving. This mindset can create financial instability, especially if income doesn’t match expectations.

The challenge is finding balance. Recognizing whether your upbringing leans toward scarcity or abundance can help you adjust your behavior to align with your long-term goals. For example, if you’re overly cautious, you might focus on taking calculated risks. If you’re prone to overspending, you might prioritize building a safety net.


Breaking Free from Limiting Narratives

So, how do you break free from money narratives that no longer serve you? Here are some practical steps inspired by Housel’s insights:

  1. Reflect on Your Past: Take time to think about the financial lessons you absorbed growing up. What did your parents teach you (explicitly or implicitly) about saving, spending, and risk? How did their attitudes influence yours?

  2. Identify Patterns: Look for recurring behaviors in your financial life. Do you avoid investing because of fear? Do you overspend to keep up appearances? Tracing these patterns back to their roots can help you understand why you act the way you do.

  3. Challenge Assumptions: Question the beliefs you hold about money. Are they based on facts, or are they outdated stories from your childhood? For example, if you believe “investing is too risky,” consider whether that belief is grounded in reality or fear.

  4. Create New Narratives: Once you’ve identified limiting beliefs, work on replacing them with healthier ones. For instance, if you grew up thinking debt is always bad, you might learn to differentiate between “good debt” (like a mortgage) and “bad debt” (like high-interest credit cards).

  5. Seek Diverse Perspectives: Surround yourself with people who have different money narratives. Their experiences can broaden your understanding and challenge your assumptions.

  6. Focus on Your Goals: Align your financial decisions with your personal values and long-term goals, rather than letting old narratives dictate your actions.


Final Thoughts: Rewriting Your Money Story

At the end of the day, your upbringing doesn’t define your financial future—but it does influence it. By exploring your money narratives, you can gain clarity about why you make the decisions you do and take steps to rewrite your story.

As Morgan Housel reminds us, “Doing well with money has little to do with how smart you are and a lot to do with how you behave.” Understanding the roots of your behavior is the first step toward making better choices.

So, ask yourself:

  • What money lessons did I learn growing up, and how do they affect me today?

  • Are my current financial habits helping me achieve my goals, or are they holding me back?

  • What new narratives can I adopt to create a healthier relationship with money?

By confronting your past and reshaping your mindset, you’re not just changing your financial habits—you’re setting the stage for a brighter, more intentional future.


TL;DR: Exploring Money Narratives

  • Money narratives are the subconscious beliefs we develop about money based on our upbringing.

  • Stories like the two investors highlight how different backgrounds lead to contrasting financial behaviors.

  • Ronald Read’s success shows how humility and discipline can turn modest beginnings into extraordinary results.

  • Scarcity mindsets can foster discipline but may lead to missed opportunities, while abundance mindsets can encourage overspending.

  • Tips to break free from limiting narratives:

    • Reflect on your past and identify patterns.

    • Challenge outdated assumptions and create new narratives.

    • Seek diverse perspectives and focus on your goals.

  • Key takeaway: Understanding your money narrative is the first step toward making smarter, more intentional financial decisions.

Subscribe to our newsletter

bottom of page